COVID-19: CXR & CT scan
CXR & CT scan
general description of imaging findings on chest x-ray and CT scan
- The typical finding is patchy ground glass opacities, which tend to be predominantly peripheral and basal (Shi et al 2/24). The number of involved lung segments increases with more severe disease. Over time, patchy ground glass opacities may coalesce into more dense consolidation.
- Infiltrates may be subtle on chest X-ray (example above from Silverstein et al).
- Findings which aren't commonly seen, and might argue for an alternative or superimposed diagnosis:
- Pleural effusion is uncommon (seen in only ~5%).
- COVID-19 doesn't appear to cause masses, cavitation, or lymphadenopathy.
sensitivity and time delay
- Limitations in the data
- Data from different studies conflict to a certain extent. This probably reflects varying levels of exposure intensity and illness severity (cohorts with higher exposure intensity and disease severity will be more likely to have radiologic changes).
- Sensitivity of CT scanning?
- Sensitivity among patients with positive RT-PCR is high. Exact numbers vary, likely reflecting variability in how scans are interpreted (there currently doesn't seem to be any precise definition of what constitutes a “positive” CT scan).
- Sensitivity of 86% (840/975) in Guan et al.
- Sensitivity of 97% (580/601) in Ai et al.
- Among patients with constitutional symptoms only (but not respiratory symptoms), CT scan may be less sensitive (e.g., perhaps ~50%)(Kanne 2/27).
- Sensitivity among patients with positive RT-PCR is high. Exact numbers vary, likely reflecting variability in how scans are interpreted (there currently doesn't seem to be any precise definition of what constitutes a “positive” CT scan).
- CT scan abnormalities might emerge before symptoms?
- Shi et al. performed CT scanning in 15 healthcare workers who were exposed to COVID-19 before they became symptomatic.
- Ground glass opacification on CT scan was seen in 14/15 patients! 9/15 patients had peripheral lung involvement (some bilateral, some unilateral).
- Emergence of CT abnormality before symptoms could be consistent with the existence of an asymptomatic carrier state (discussed above).
- Chest X-ray
- Sensitivity of chest X-ray is lower than CT scan for subtle opacities.
- In Guan et al., the sensitivity of chest x-ray was 59%, compared to 86% for CT scan.
- In Arentz et al. from Washington State, clear chest X-ray was only recorded in 1/21 patients. However a variety of different findings were reported (including bilateral reticular nodular opacities, ground-glass opacities, focal consolidation, and pulmonary edema).
further information
- An illustrated guide to the chest CT in COVID-19 (PulmCCM, by Jon-Emile Kenny)